One Free Korea OneFreeKorea freekorea.us home faq about news blogs plan-b camps interviews google earth

Chinese Police Raid LiNK Refuge, Arrest Three U.S. Activists and Six Refugees

Update 1: I’m going to bump this post up a few times. Meanwhile, I second Kyochan’s advice: Digg the story. I didn’t have an account, but it only took a few seconds to sign up. And I see that Reporters Without Borders is e-mailing half the world over … Saddam Hussein’s execution! Well, here, here! Let’s exhume the old bus-bombing rapist. Scroll down to see my response, and RSF’s reply to that. They claim not to have an opinion on Saddam’s execution, although they’re sending out a weighted sampling of world opinion to what must be a gargantuan list of bloggers. And to think I used to have an RSF button on my old blogger site.

Original Post: Returning from a day out with my family today, I found that I’d received emails from several Liberty in North Korea members (thank you), including its Executive Director, Adrian Hong. For new readers, LiNK is among several groups of courageous activists who form a modern underground railroad along which North Korean refugees escape the repression and starvation of their homeland, through China, to refuge in South Korea or other places (much more information on these refugees here).

Adrian, at least two other LiNK members, and six refugees were arrested by the Chinese just before Christmas. Adrian (media interviews here, here, and here) and the other LiNK members were released, but the six refugees face a very grim fate:

The six refugees in jail in Shenyang include two orphan boys, ages 16 and 17; a 22-year-old woman; and three women in their 40s. One of the older women is the mother of a 19-year-old who made it to safety in the U.S. consulate last year and is awaiting resettlement in the U.S. along with two orphan boys — if China lets them leave. One of the women has relatives in Hawaii; another has family in South Korea.

The six were captured just before Christmas along with two Americans who had been sheltering them in safe houses in another city and were accompanying them to the consulate. Their rescuers — young women who don’t want their names used — belong to Liberty in North Korea, or LINK, a U.S. non-profit dedicated to helping the refugees. LINK’s director, Adrian Hong, was also arrested — pulled out of his hotel room in Beijing and taken to a prison cell in Shenyang. The three rescuers were deported this week.

[subscriber link here; longer excerpt here]

I have deeply mixed emotions on reading this news. I am relieved that my friend Adrian will not share the fate of Phillip Buck, Steve Kim, and Choi Yung Hun, who spent years in Chinese prisons. And as I write, amidst my sleeping family, I feel despair for these refugees. Past reports tell us that the Chinese will jab wires through their wrists or noses and drag them back to North Korea. Because they have had contact with foreigners opposed to the regime, they are as good as dead on arrival. A common punishment for this sort of betrayal of the slave state’s total control is public execution by firing squad, before a captive audience. That was the fate of the people in this guerrilla camera footage.

(China’s abuse and repatriation of these refugees is a flagrant violation of the 1951 U.N. Convention on Refugees, which China signed, but of course, China really doesn’t care, and neither does the U.N., nor do the hypocrites who comprise the majority of the Human Rights Industry. Ditto the “managed famine” that killed two million North Koreans during its largest-ever arms binge.)

Why the crackdown? Because the food situation in North Korea is deteriorating fast, Kim Jong Il’s regime is under an increasingly effective financial attack from the United States Treasury Department, and the Chinese are doing everything they can to preserve their North Korean puppet and partial colony. They may also be seeking to slave-catch their way to a refugee-free Olympics by 2008.

As sad as that may be, this does remove one agonizing question from the shoulders of activists who had adopted a less confrontational approach with China for fear that we’d see just this result. China is testing the world’s reaction, and I share China’s confidence that Ban Ki Moon and the U.N. won’t do anything particularly effective to interfere. South Korea ceased to be a significant part of this discussion, except as a reluctant destination for North Korea refugees, around the time Ban became its foreign minister. The U.S. role has sadly never gone beyond token gestures and lip service, notwithstanding a federal statute requiring our embassies to “facilitate the submission of applications” for asylum by North Koreans. There can be no stronger argument for the adoption of more controversial tactics on our part, to match China’s, to something louder, more public, and if possible, more economically costly, and more humiliating for China and its diplomats: everyone else has betrayed the North Korean people.

What can you do to save these people, and those who will follow? First, I’d encourage you to join or contribute to LiNK and to keep an eye on their site. And while the Chinese are used to dealing with dissent by shooting their way through it, I believe that enough of an e-mail and telephone blitz on their embassy would at least be a factor in how they deal with these six people (here, I would deeply appreciate any sympathetic links fellow bloggers would be kind enough to provide, to help spread the word about China’s conduct and encourage reconsideration of attending the Beijing Olympics, which are one reason for these slave hunts). Finally, this may call for some ferociously creative activism, possibly in concert with other groups that oppose the Chinese dictatorship’s trampling of human rights. The only certain way not to miss it is to join LiNK.

Update: And what is the Human Rights Industry up to today?

RSF sends:

Each week, Reporters Without Borders publishes the opinions of bloggers throughout the world on an important development, thereby broadening the range of views on current events. The blogs are selected by a team of bloggers of very diverse origins and cultures. We give priority to blogs which Internet users have written in their mother tongue, and we translate them into English and French.

This week : what bloggers from France, Irak, Uruguay, Iran, USA… say about Saddam Hussein’s execution

I respond:

Well, I see that RSF has its borders back, or else it has officially lost all contact with its sense of mission purpose, and proportion.

A tyrant is tried, convicted, and hanged for genocide. You pull out all the stops to inform me that people are outraged in Ecuador. Two million North Koreans are deliberately starved to death in what this scholarly report, commissioned by Vaclav Havel and Elie Wiesel, calls a “crime against humanity.” And you ignore the fact that it’s about to happen again.

This, I submit, is why you have ceased to be a force for the dignity and protection of the voiceless millions.

Last week, the Chinese arrested six North Korean refugees. Unlike Saddam, they are innocent of any crime. Unlike Saddam, they will not face trial. Two of them are children. China will soon send them to almost certain death in North Korea, probably by firing squad in public, in flagrant violation of the UN Refugee Convention. The UNHCR, cowed and possibly bought by China, will not utter one word on their behalf. These refugees were arrested with three human rights activists, members of a courageous group called LiNK.

Will you help us save them, or will you go on trying to dig up Saddam?

If the death of one man — particularly one so unworthy of being mourned, and who was afforded the rare luxury of a trial — is statistically insignificant, the consensus of the Ecuadorian street about it is surely even less significant.

You’ve become just another industry following the dictates of your markets. You have ceased to lead in a direction of moral significance. Have the decency to seek gainful employment.

Ecuador, Uruguay, France, same diff. RSF responds:

We’re just publising and translating blogger’s opinions (and not all of them regret saddam’s execution). Nothing more.
This has nothing to do with the RSF position on this issue.

And I respond:

Great. So you’re using your resources on an issue on which you have no opinion, then?

I will be speaking with the heads of the North Korean Freedom Coalition and LiNK today. We’d love to have your assistance in saving these innocent North Korean lives.

And back to RSF:

We have opinions on Press Freedom, which is our role. And we very often denounce what happening in North Korea. Ex, this country is on our list of the “13 enemies of the Internet” :

http://www.rsf.org/int_blackholes_en.php3?id_mot=260&annee=2007&Valider=OK Or http://www.rsf.org/article.php3?id_article=1073

And suddenly, RSF snaps back into its “role,” which is protecting press freedom, and which relates to Saddam Hussein’s hanging how, exactly? But snaps to RSF for covering itself, although not once have I seen any of these e-mailings devoted primarily or exclusively to North Korea, nor, for the life of me. And while I strongly believe in the need for more freedom of information in North Korea, I think the last thing that North Koreans are worrying about — you know, with the famine probably returning and all — is Internet access. So I said, simply:

Saddam? Press freedom? Connection, please?

How sad that so many organizations with so much power to lead have chosen to squander it instead.

Chi-Town said,

January 5, 2007 @ 2:56 am

I think human rights activist should use every opportunity to embarrass China during 2008 Olympics.

The human rights activist really should coordinate their efforts to bring attention to China’s cruelty.

Are You NKay? | :: Refugees and LiNK Members Arrested in Shenyang :: January :: 2007 North Korean Human Rights blogged by a member of Liberty in North Korea said,

January 5, 2007 @ 4:05 am

[…] Update: OneFreeKorea suggests clogging the embassy lines with your piece of mind, among other things. Heck, I’d Digg that post over mine. Filed under: North Korea, LiNK | 4:58 am […]

kyochan said,

January 5, 2007 @ 11:47 am

If anyone has a Digg account, please Digg this story. Since the original story is behind WSJ’s subscription wall, this is the best way to spread the news.

China repatriates refugees because they believe they can get away with breaking UN conventions. Do not let it happen. If these six refugees reach get enough media attention in time, hopefully they could be saved.

usinkorea said,

January 5, 2007 @ 12:21 pm

I can’t remember the previous comments about Hollywood doing something with this kind of NK-related material. I remember very vaguely some mentioning that feelers have actually begun in that direction.

God’s speed to it.

I think it is a match made in heaven (no pun intended).

I would think if you just plot down a list of catch-words/phrases, it should intrests some fo the big time producers and directors:

underground railroad, concentration camps, abductees, mass starvation, nuclear weapons, political oppression to an extent that would have made Hitler and Stalin envious, and so on.

I mean ——-

there are so many REAL LIFE stories invovled in this area — a good screen writer should be able to churn out INCREDIBLY lasting scenes not just to make a hit, but scenes that would end up being historic just in the film industry.

I mean, the stories are so compelling —– meaning — they would SO EASILY yank hard at the heart strings of average viewers around the world —

and the “themes” so universal and lasting —- a movie telling these stories together would go down as a historic Hollywood moment.

In the hands of a director like Spieberg or one of the other top tier directors —— it would not only make a ton of money, it would be something Hollywood elites could pat themselves on the back for making for years and years.

I really, deeply, and truly believe ——–
—–the nature of the stories surrounding North Korea are a match made in heaven for Hollywood.

They do not have to “dream up” a script to find compelling stories to tell.

They don’t have to worry about whether the theme or setting will interest the audience. The Cold War came to an end, but a horrible, medieval despotic regime is right there out there today screaming at the world to pay attention to it by testing nuclear bombs and ICBMS and building massive concentration camps for its own people.

The regime’s evil dictator does not have to be sexed up to portray as evil. He is a character straight out of a James Bond movie - complete with “charismatic hair” and quirks like having whole buildings decicated to his world movie collection - and complete with a hand-picked pack of flower girls to meet his needs taken from all over the country at a young age.

I mean —– seriously —- really seriously — it is a no-brainer for Hollywood.

North Korea mixes together in one package —– things that have become stereotypes of several movie themes.

If you wrote a Hollywood-style blockbuster script based on real facts everybody knows about North Korea —- 300 years from now, people would assume it was fiction. - that it was too “unbelievable” to be a true story.

That is how compelling the story should be from Hollywood’s point of view.

And besides the money they would make off such a movie handled by a top director and producer —- it would also do MUCH to stroke Hollywood’s ego. Besides the love of money, they also want to be viewed as “making a difference” and feel the need to take up social causes and speak out on politics.

I really, really can’t think of one thing that would make such a movie a bad idea.

It seems like such a perfect match, it should be something they’d go hog wild for once they got the big picture.

GI Korea said,

January 6, 2007 @ 2:38 pm

I got you linked but I hold little hope that the UN or the news media will do anything about this. If they can feel sympathetic for Saddam they assuredly feel the same sympathy for Kim Jong-il.

USinKorea, I have thought the same thing in regards to a NK movie. I always thought a Schindler’s List type of atmosphere for a movie that is set in a North Korean prison than follows the characters finally escaping North Korea as refugees into China and then ultimately arrested by the Chinese and sent back to NK to their deaths would be a hugely emotional movie that would bring the needed attention to what is going on in North Korea. I hold little hope that Hollywood would ever make such a movie. I would actually prefer such a movie be made by South Koreans to shame the SK government into action.

Yu said,

January 6, 2007 @ 3:28 pm

Isn’t harboring illegal immigrants… ILLEGAL in the US as well? And in probably every other country in the world. Did these 6 North Koreans formally apply for asylum status with the Chinese gov? Probably not. LINK is doing North Korean emigrants a disservice by encouraging them to bypass the Chinese legal system and go directly to their “refuges”. Hopefully, the illegal immigrant problem will be mitigated by progress on the construction of the border fence.

LiNK Members Arrested in China at ROK Drop said,

January 6, 2007 @ 4:04 pm

[…] One Free Korea has a must read posting about the arrest of Liberty in North Korea (LiNK) members by Chinese authorities who were helping refugees escape from North Korea via China.  In addition to their arrests six North Korean refugees were also arrested that will surely be executed once returned to North Korea: […]

Joshua said,

January 6, 2007 @ 6:37 pm

Yu, If a Mexican illegal alien is arrested by ICE (the successor to INS), ICE legally must ask if he fears persecution if returned to Mexico. If he persists in his claim that he fears persecution and asks for aslyum, he’s legally entitled to a hearing. That’s because the United States, like China, is a signatory to the UN Refugee Convention of 1951. But unlike China, the United States complies with its terms.

Furthermore, if the alien claims fear of torture, he has a separate basis to request to be paroled into the United States per the UN Convention Against Torture. Both of those processes are fraught with fraud, keep our immigration system very busy, and cost the US taxpayers a fortune. Yet we do it.

To claim political asylum in the United States, you need only request it at the U.S. border or upon apprehension. To claim political asylum in China, you need one of two things: the help of people who are willing to harbor you, in defiance of the unelected thugs who run the PRC, or a very long bong hit.

kumar said,

January 6, 2007 @ 6:57 pm

Yu does not understand the issue.

esther said,

January 6, 2007 @ 7:09 pm

agreed kumar.

joshua, thanks for publicizing this.

Joshua said,

January 6, 2007 @ 7:16 pm

Yu is a PRC shill (writing in via a proxy server in Boston). He understands as much as he wants to understand. But I invite him to go on defending the indefensible. When I’m through with him, Chairman Mao won’t be smiling.

Kumar, did you change your e-mail address?

kumar said,

January 6, 2007 @ 9:41 pm

yep. add the first initial of my last name to the end of the original one and you’ve got it.

usinkorea said,

January 6, 2007 @ 11:04 pm

On the movie..

I can invision one of those Hollywood movies where they get many big time stars to do little parts — with the story being expansive —- covering a lot of topics on the NK front.

I can’t remember the title, but I think it was an HBO production some years ago dealing with how the AIDS epidemic was first recognized. It focused primarily on the Center For Desease Control, but the credits were a Who’s Who of Hollywood.

It would make perfect sense to put forward such a united front on North Korea as well. If they can come out with a handful of movies on Tibet and the plight of the Dalai Lama and get significant interest from a range of big players in Hollywood —–

—-North Korea should fit like second skin.

Tell stories about life inside Korea.

Tell stories about the Korean-Americans and South Koreans and others working clandestinely in China.

The number of immensly compelling stories that can be put on the screeen and that would reach out and absolutely grab hold of an audies are so numerous.

It should be a script writer and producer’s dream.

All it needs is money and a top tier director to make it a historical landmark in Hollywood film.

As the years pass, it will be more and more disappointing that the only people who have decided to do something worthwhile via a non-documentary production has been the guys from South Park….

kumar said,

January 7, 2007 @ 3:08 am

btw, re: hollywood

already in the works.

GI Korea said,

January 7, 2007 @ 4:16 pm

kumar,

If a North Korea related Hollywood movie is in the works is it actually going to be big budget theater release or just some low budget made for TV movie that hardly anyone will ever see?

OneFreeKorea » Gerry Bevers, Tokdo, and the Heckler’s Veto said,

January 7, 2007 @ 8:58 pm

[…] I’m amazed at how all eyes can follow the swarm of bees and yet miss the pink elephant in the room. So do you really love your country? Do you have a pair? Wanna fight the illegal occupation of half your country and the enslavement of a third of its people, even when some actual courage is required? Then go to the DMZ, or any Hanchongryon rally, and shout, “Wonsan-nun uri ttang!” Unlike Tokdo, there are actual people who live in the northern half of Korea. And uppity talk at Japan is pretty much a no-balls-required proposition, although it won’t free or save anyone. It’s even possible to do something legitimately courageous, or something simple, convenient, and practical to actually help some of them, but few will. The cries of 23 million enslaved Koreans fall on deaf ears, and will for as long as they still live. As a wise man once said, […]

snow said,

January 8, 2007 @ 2:59 am

If there really is a Hollywood movie being made about the situation in North Korea, I wonder if they’ll somehow work it into the story about how the US is to blame for it all.

Joshua said,

January 8, 2007 @ 6:01 am

Just my thoughts. Would also be ironic of they could get Alec Baldwin of “Team America” fame to star.

OneFreeKorea » Chosun Ilbo Draws ‘Line of Death!’ said,

January 9, 2007 @ 7:26 am

[…] I don’t believe this.  The VANK losers are … diplomats?  “0 wad some Power the giftie gie us / To see oursels as ithers see us! / It wad frae monie a blunder free us….”  LiNK’s members are braving the very real risk of years in Chinese prisons to save actual Korean lives, and a bunch of cyber-thugs in PC-bangs are crowned as the new Righteous Army? Due to such efforts, maps in various countries are changing the “Sea of Japan” reference to include the name “East Sea.” […]

OneFreeKorea » Sorry ‘Bout That: How a South Korean Consulate Helped Doom Nine Family Members of Its POWs said,

January 17, 2007 @ 8:41 pm

[…] *  December 2006:  The Shenyang Six, refugees who are in Chinese jails now, and who may soon be sent back to North Korea. […]

OneFreeKorea » It’s Time for Jay Lefkowitz to Resign said,

February 19, 2007 @ 1:53 pm

[…] The word that Eberstadt may have cause to rethink here is “inexplicable.”  And when Washington has just cut the knees out from under Japan, who can still believe that it will be willing to apply the pressure of our good offices to China’s barbaric and unlawful treatment of North Korea’s refugees, or the comfort women on whom its men prey? The critical missing piece for getting this underground railroad up and running is safe passage through China. But because the South Korean government fears antagonizing the North and the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees is too timid to face down Beijing, China’s opposition to this rescue mission has gone unchallenged. Only the United States is in a position to help overcome Beijing’s recalcitrance. […]

OneFreeKorea » How a U.S. Consul Helped Kill Six North Korean Refugees said,

March 4, 2007 @ 12:20 pm

[…] Back in January, I told you the story of the Shenyang Six, a group of six North Korean refugees who sought refuge from persecution and starvation in their homeland, and how the Chinese authorities, following their long-standing custom, hauled them back to spend whatever remains of their lives in Kim Jong Il’s gulag.  Readers will recall that LiNK’s (Liberty in North Korea) Executive Director, Adrian Hong, was also arrested by Chinese police and held for three days.  What I did not know until now is that the indirect cause of this tragedy was a U.S. Consul who was willing to flout a binding U.S. statute and consign six innocents to certain death.  I have asked our Shenyang Consulate for its side of the story, and I’ve promised to print their entire response.  But from Adrian Hong’s statement below, now a part of the Congressional Record, it looks like our own State Department has less regard for U.S. statutes, or the lives of innocent people, than it does for Kim Jong Il’s feelings, or Hu Jintao’s.  And that calls into question just who and what our diplomatic facilities in China even represent. […]

OneFreeKorea » The Shenyang Six Are Freed said,

August 20, 2007 @ 8:43 pm

[…] Do you still remember their story, the arrest of Adrian Hong and the courageous LiNK activists, and the shame on our Consul General in Shenyang?  I had given up all hope, but others did not, and their persistence has been repaid with six lives.   WASHINGTON, D.C., Aug. 20 - Liberty in North Korea (LiNK) today announced that six North Korean refugees imprisoned by Chinese authorities last December were recently released from a prison in Shenyang. The six - which include two teenage boys, one woman in her early twenties, and three older women - were arrested in Beijing last December after seeking asylum at a foreign mission in China. They arrived in South Korea on July 19. […]

RSS feed for comments on this post · TrackBack URI

Leave a Comment