KCNA cites debunked accusations to deny human rights violations

It all started with a piece of web journalism that printed the demonstrably untrue accusations of two men whose views were never newsworthy, and which would never have been published had they been researched. One is a notorious denier of North Korea’s crimes against humanity who claims to have traveled widely within North Korea, meaning he’s either too blind to read a cuckoo clock at high noon or prevaricating, probably to protect his business interests there. The other is a combustible man (as in, warning: contents under pressure) without any basis for his mean-spirited accusation — an accusation he now both repeats and regrets in one incoherent post that also concedes the broader truth of Pyongyang’s crimes (but only as asserted by numerous other witnesses). Yet last week, their accusations graduated into official KCNA propaganda talking points in Pyongyang’s smear campaign against its accusers:

A journalist of Ireland on Oct. 29, 2014 in an article dedicated to the internet magazine The Diplomat said that Pak Yon Mi, 21-year old girl who defected from north Korea, spoke about “the serious human rights situation” in north Korea in tears at the World Youth Summit held in Dublin early in October and BBC, Al Jazeera, Daily Mail and other media gave wide publicity to it, but not a few critics claimed what she said was contrary to the truth, expressing skepticism about her speech.

Swiss businessman Felix Abt who had worked in north Korea for seven years till 2009 asserted that most of the stories told by those defectors from the north were not confirmed and clearly hyped or they were sheer lies.

Denying the claim mader by Pak Yon Mi, comparing Dublin Canal with a river in the area where she had lived, that she saw dead bodies afloat over the river every morning, Abt refuted her story by saying he had been to north Korea many times but had never seen dead bodies, showing a picture of children in north Korea wading in rivers with joy.

Challenging the assertion of Ri Kwang Chol, defector from the north, who said there is no physically disabled person in north Korea due to infanticide, Abt recalled that Pyongyang dispatched disabled players to the Paralymic Games held in Inchon, south Korea.

Michael Bassett, who served the U.S. forces as an expert for north Korea in the Demilitarized Zone on the Korean Peninsula for years, said that the story made by Pak Yon Mi, defector from the north, was a shee lie, that Pak described the human rights situation in north Korea as a “massacre”, prompted by her intention to create a great sensation and that such anti-DPRK organizations in south Korea as “Freedom Factory” were behind her. Bassett, referring to the fact that Pak Yon Mi sent him an article refuting his story, ridiculed that her English was too perfect though she was a foreigner. [KCNA]

Congratulations, guys. Your reputations are now secure.

5 Responses

  1. Well, at least Felix gets his well deserved praise from the world’s most reputable news source, KCNA [sorry, The Onion, you’re just going to have to give up your throne to such a worthy adversary].

  2. Oh, and it’s cute that Bassett and Abt have a little conversation in the comments section of that blathering idiot’s blog.

  3. For the record, here is exactly what I told The Diplomat magazine:

    quote

    I suppose many of the stories that defectors present are true, even though they cannot be verified. I ONLY challenge claims that are obviously exaggerated or plain false. Let me illustrate that with two examples: Park Yeon-mi, a prominent defector spoke a few weeks ago of an ongoing HOLOCAUST in North Korea and said that plastic bottles in the Royal Canal reminded her of “floating bodies” that “appear in North Korean creeks every morning”. I widely traveled the country and didn’t come across dead bodies. Sure, there may have been floating bodies in rivers in the terrible crisis years of the nineties when 600.000 people starved to death according to an estimate by the U.N. official who was then supervising foreign aid during the famine in the country. But since then things have clearly changed for the better (no more mass starvation, recovery of the economy etc.) which many activists do not recognize. Another defector and doctor claims, for example, that ALL people born with defects are systematically killed. However, I have met handicapped North Koreans and know foreign NGOs who work with handicapped people in the country. And a few weeks ago North Korea even sent a team to the Paralympic games in South Korea.

    unquote –

    And here is what I posted on my Facebook page: https://www.facebook.com/ACapitalistInNorthKorea/photos/a.527222523969386.122586.520006091357696/854807961210839/?type=1

  4. All that water you’re carrying for the usual suspects and your former business partners getting heavy?

    Fascinating.

  5. The fact that it’s not just the same regime, … but in most cases, the same actual individual people who presided over the mass death and continual persecution of North Koreans, that are still in power doesn’t turn your stomach a bit?

    Says pretty much all we need to know about what lines your stomach.