One Free Korea OneFreeKorea freekorea.us home faq about news blogs plan-b camps interviews google earth

Wiesenthal Center Condemns Anti-Semitic ‘Monnara Iunnara’ Comic Book

A few initial observations before I relate the rest of this story.  First, I predict that no embassies will be burned and no riots will ensue as a result of these comics. 

Second is a story that I may never have told here, but will tell now.  In February of 2004, when British newspapers first reported that North Korea was killing men, women, and kids in a gas chamber at Camp 22, near Hoeryong, North Hamgyeong Province, I (and others) contacted Rabbi Abraham Cooper for the first time.  This led to a brief e-mail exchange between Rabbi Cooper and myself, and inspired me to begin this blog.  Since that time, Rabbi Cooper has been one of the commanding figures of the movement to expose and end the atrocities in North Korea, to include key support for the North Korean Human Rights Act, addressing Freedom House’s North Korean human rights conference in July of 2005, meetings with Kim Moon Soo and John Bolton, and more acts than I could describe here.  Rabbi Cooper’s response to the inhuman murder of innocent North Koreans was immediate, strong, persistent, and highly effective.

I can’t help but believe that his efforts have earned him the right to be heard when he says this:

We were shocked to recently learn that a book from your very successful series, Monnara lunnara by Professor Lee Won-Bak is replete with classic hateful and dangerous antisemitic caricatures and themes.  For your information I am inclosing a few of the most notorious, for they echo Nazi canards like those found in Der Sturmer and the Protocols of the Elders of Zion by recycling various Jewish conspiracies like Jewish control of the media and money, Jews profiting from war, and even the alleged reason for the 9/11 attacks was that, “Jews use money and the media as weapons in America to do as they want.” In addition, the author even alleges that the “Final obstacle to success” is a so-called “Wall of the Jews.” Ms Park, we urge Gimm-Young Publishers to review for itself the slanders in this book that historically have led to antisemitism, violence, hatred and even genocide.  We respectfully suggest that you take steps to replace the litany of hate and instead provide young Korean readers with the facts about the Jewish people and our religion and values.

A translated sample from the The Wiesenthal Center’s press release; click for full size:

They were also classy enough to thank the expats and bloggers, most of whom I presume to be non-Jews, who brought this story to light and translated the images.  I would be more specific and tip my hat to Sonagi, Reading Iunnara, and of course, Robert Koehler (I’ll add Robert’s request for some decent bagels in Seoul to my petition right after the request for my still-unrecouped share of the take from the international financial conspiracy).

Let’s hope the publisher’s reaction, and that of most of Korean society, are thoughtful and introspective.  No ethnic group, including Koreans, would want to be depicted this way.

Update:  This story is certainly not over, but people of African descent undoubtedly experience more discrimination in Asia than Jews do.  Japanprobe has an update on a related situation in Japan.  In the event Family Mart hasn’t actually removed some vehemently racist books from its stores, I wonder if the NAACP would be interested in this story.

The Marmot’s Hole » Wiesenthal Center denounces Korean comic book said,

February 8, 2007 @ 9:02 pm

[…] Good. the Simon Wiesenthal Center has denounced Rhie Won-bok’s comic “Far Country, Neighbor Country” for its anti-Semitic content (HT to One Free Korea): “The images in question in Monnara Iunnara echo classic Nazi canards like those found in Der Sturmer and the Protocols of the Elders of Zion by recycling various Jewish conspiracies like Jewish control of the media and money, Jews profiting from war, and even the reason for the 9/11 attacks was that, ‘Jews use money and the media as weapons in America to do as they want’,” charged Rabbi Abraham Cooper, associate dean of the Wiesenthal Center, adding, “the author also even alleges that the ‘final obstacle to success’ in the U.S. for Korean-Americans is a so-called ‘Wall of the Jews’.” […]

Japundit » Oops, they did it again! said,

February 9, 2007 @ 9:00 pm

[…] One of South Korea’s most prolific and leading authors, Professor Lee Won-bok, in a new book from his series, Monnara Iunnara (Distant Countries and Neighboring Countries) –which studies countries in a comic book format and for the last 20 years have sold over 10 million copies to South Koreans — has published images in his book that reportedly echo classic Nazi canards about Jews like those found in Der Sturmer and the Protocols of the Elders of Zion by recycling various Jewish conspiracies like Jewish control of the media and world finance, Jews profiting from war, and even the reason for the 9/11 attacks was due to the Jews. Or something like that. Maybe our Japundits in Korea can explain all this in the comments section. […]

Henry said,

February 9, 2007 @ 9:47 pm

This is disgraceful, if some company portrayed Koreans in a malicious manner the uproar would be tremendous. Maybe I missed an earlier post but what exactly is this comic supposed to be about, other then racism and antisemitism?

The Four Color Media Monitor said,

February 12, 2007 @ 2:03 pm

An anti-Semitic and racist comic book in Korea…

One Free Korea reports about the Simon Wiesenthal Center’s research on a Judeophobic and racist comic book called “Monnara Iunnara”. The North end of Korea may be where this kind of prejudice mainly stems from, but even the South end has problems wi…

Nicholas said,

February 14, 2007 @ 2:24 am

I’m a Korean Linguist. Does anyone know exactly which book this came out of? I have the 먼나라 이웃나라 for Korea, but I don’t know exactly which one this comes out of. I just want to see the exact context for interest’s sake.

Joe Mondello said,

February 15, 2007 @ 1:45 am

Nicholas, it’s from volume 10.
By the way, this story has been reported (in a somewhat less than satisfying manner) by MBC and SBS. Have a look at my blog for a translation of each report.

Sonagi said,

February 15, 2007 @ 9:16 am

Volume 10 is one of two on the United States. It is the volume on the American people. The other, volume 11, is on American history. You can see a few choice images from the book in their original form along with an English translation here:

http://www.flickr.com/photos/62177820@N00/

Sonagi said,

February 15, 2007 @ 9:33 am

BTW, Joshua, if you haven’t had a chance yet, head over to the Marmot’s for a new entry on the Korean media attention to the book. Korean netizens are scratching their heads trying to figure how American Jews found out about this book since it’s written in Korean!

Joshua said,

February 15, 2007 @ 9:58 am

Seen it.

OneFreeKorea » The Han Breeds a New Monster: Anti-Semitism said,

February 16, 2007 @ 7:37 am

[…] The Simon Wiesenthal Center’s reaction to an anti-Semitic volume of the best-selling graphic series “Monnara Iunnara” has hit the Chosun Ilbo.  My wife had sent me the Korean link yesterday, which was a day when I just didn’t have the time to write more.  There has actually been a moderate amount of coverage of this story in the Korean press.  But wait until you see the author’s explanation: Rhie apologized for hurting Jewish feelings and said he was neither anti-Semitic nor out to criticize Jews. “I drew the cartoons based on data I gathered while living in the U.S. for two years,” he said.   […]

RSS feed for comments on this post · TrackBack URI

Leave a Comment