Monthly Archive: August, 2005

Is South Korea Still Free?

I knew that the South Korean government took some extraordinary measures to shield its visiting Northern bretheren from pesky free speech, but things have apparently gone further downhill than I had realized. Listen to what the new dissidents are reporting: Doh Hee-yun, the head of the Citizens’ Coalition for Human Rights for Abductees and North Korean Refugees, said Thursday two inspectors from Mapo Police Station followed him from morning to night during the celebrations. He said the inspectors tailed him...

The Chosun Ilbo and Censorship

While I would agree that the current South Korean government has tried to intimidate and weaken opposition newspapers, I nonconcur with the implication that disputing the accuracy of articles is a subterfuge for censorship. I’m not comfortable with ajumma-state arbitration/oversight boards that are vulnerable to political packing–fair enough. I have the same concerns about our own FCC and the Fairness Doctrine. But if the Chosun Ilbo wants free-speech martyr status, it will first need to persuade me that there’s a...

The Cost of Reunification

The Chosun Ilbo has an interesting piece on the subject. I’m not among those who would try to minimize the cost, although the estimates I’ve read are so diverse that it’s impossible to come up with a statistically significant average. Some have estimated that it would cost a trillion dollars. Others have suggested that the Korean “peace dividend” would pay for it, which I think is simply wrong. Reuinification will mean a dramatic deterioration in security over the short-term, as...

112429894330182304

They will never rest in peace. Christopher Hitchens recently grabbed me when he spoke of those who would “ventriloquize” the dead for their own purposes. Do you suppose these two girls ever imagined, or wanted, to become icons for emotional manipulation in the service of repression? It’s always tragic, of course, when a life lasts for so many fewer years than it should; sadder still when that loss was both preventable and mostly unmourned. It isn’t my intent to ventriloquize...

HRC Update: Miranda Rights for Koreans?

The Human Rights Commission is calling on the cops to read people a Miranda warning at the time of an arrest. I realize what an extraordinary reach of activism it is to suggest that the Korean legal system should recognize the precedental authority of a case decided in a foreign court decades ago, so overlook the flimsiness of it on legal grounds. From the few Korean appellate opinions I’ve read, the concepts of judicial restraint, rules of statutory construction, and...

A Date That Will Live in Irony

August 15, 2005, a date on which more bullshit flowed than one snarky blogger could possibly step around, so I’ll let the stories pretty much speak for themselves. In case you’re new here, this is the anniversary of the date on which American soldiers–supported by Russian invaders further north–entered Seoul before passing the reigns of government to the Koreans themselves. Yes, things could have been faster and smoother, and Korea’s first rulers were certainly not Jeffersonian democrats, but what’s most...

Misunderstanding, or a Very Orwellian Liberation Day?

The following bloggers report that they’ve been blocked in Korea: The Asia Pages, The Big Hominid, and The Lost Nomad. Simon World claims it affects both Blogger and Typepad, which would seem to affect both this site and NKZone. Some commenters on these sites report being able to load the pages, but I’m not sure who’s in Korea, and who’s on or off-post. Readers in Korea, can you read me? What an Orwellian way that would be to celebrate one’s...

OFK Interview with Nicholas Eberstadt

My deepest thanks to Nicholas Eberstadt of the American Enterprise Institute for agreeing to a telephone interview. Eberstadt is one of Washington’s most highly regarded Korea experts. The interview ended up lasting a full hour. Nothing has been edited out, although I missed a word here and there because I’m not a stenographer. Still, this is pretty close to a verbatim transcript; Nick Eberstadt is one of those rare individuals who speaks in complete sentences. All comments in brackets and...

OFK Interview with Nicholas Eberstadt: After the Talks

My deepest thanks to Nicholas Eberstadt of the American Enterprise Institute for agreeing to a telephone interview for OFK readers. Eberstadt is one of Washington’s most highly regarded Korea experts. The interview ended up lasting a full hour. Nothing has been edited out save one abortive “I don’t know” answer, although I may have I missed a few words because I’m no stenographer. Still, this is pretty close to a verbatim transcript. Nick Eberstadt is one of those rare individuals...

Our New Euphemism: ‘Pragmatic Patriotism’

The Chosun Ilbo recently made the grave mistake of commissioning a survey of young citizens’ attitudes to commemorate the 60th anniversary of independence from Japan. The Chosun deserves credit for reporting the distressing results rather than burying them, but the factual basis for some of its analysis is not evident to the reader: The survey by Gallup Korea of 833 individuals born between 1980 and 1989 also found a marked shift in attitude to North Korea and the South’s traditional...