Korea’s ‘Legal’ System–A Devastating Contrast to the Rule of Law

Finally, I can’t restrain my enthusiasm over this Korea Times column, which completely nails my own complaints about the Korean legal system. As someone who dealt regularly with the deficiencies that system on a regular basis while a JAG officer in Korea, its awfulness has been a favorite rant of mine since the early days of this blog (ht The Marmot). The context is the “Hong Kong Eleven,” a group of violent South Korean union thugs who went to Hong...

113743118242916279

Iraq Watch. This week’s theme seems to be the state and the rule of law. Just as the rule of law disintegrates when the state is unresponsive to the will of the people, reestablishing the rule of law is essential to allowing the people to express their will peacefully. Sir Robert Thompson, the great British theorist of counterinsurgency, would likely have made the reconstitution of Iraq’s police the first priority, even before the army. The best organisation to be responsible...

Revolution Watch / China

[Updated; Scroll down.] If the military and the peasantry unite as one, then none on this earth could possibly subvert them. –MaoRural uprisings in China are becoming so frequent, it’s getting hard to keep track of them. BEIJING (Reuters) – China has sealed off a village in southern Guangdong province after days of protests over land grabs ended at the weekend in clashes with police that killed a teenage girl, two residents said on Monday. Last week’s protest came a...

113738664422079571

Mystery Solved: Not that the speculation excited me much, but Kim Jong Il is in southern China. Frequent brief disappearances are de rigeur for this particular despot. The predictable triumph of exuberance over experience is the reporting that this time, he’s touring factories and learning about economic reform! Some people have been holding in that lungful of smoke for almost nine years now. The truth is that this horse has been led to that water before. . . .

South Korean Street Thugs Silence U.S. Ambassador, But Not for Long

[Updated 15 Jan 06] I had meant to say something earlier about how South Korea’s culture of politics-by-thuggery has now touched even the U.S. Ambassador to Korea, Alexander Vershbow. The Flying Yangban’s observations have inspired me to add more, beyond the expression of my strong agreement with those observations. Finally, after years of watching U.S. ambassadors work the cocktail circuit while the propaganda war was lost in the streets below, a U.S. ambassador has the vision and guts to do...

Greed’s Graveyard

The Washington Post has finally taken note of Hyundai’s troubles in North Korea, which continues to be a black hole for South Korean won: [S]ince South Korea opened up friendly relations with the North in the late 1990s, more than 1,000 South Korean firms have gone bankrupt or lost significant investments in North Korea, according to South Korea’s Unification Ministry. Most were small, low-tech enterprises involved in textile-making and rudimentary housewares. But the problems at Hyundai have shown that the...

113720765658420780

The Succession Race for U.N. General Secretary has begun, in case that sort of thing interests you. South Korean Foreign Minister Ban Ki Moon, a key salesman for appeasing the North, wants the job, but this WaPo piece also notes that any of the five permanent members of the Security Council could block him, which I certainly hope we would. Asia think it’s its turn; John Bolton doesn’t agree. Update: I could support this candidate, although that’s probably too good...

DiTrani Will Head U.S. Intel Effort Against North Korea

My acquaintance (heh) Ambassador DiTrani is headed for a high-level intel position covering North Korea: The former U.S. special envoy for North Korea Joseph DeTrani was on Wednesday appointed to the newly created post of “mission manager” for North Korea under the director for national intelligence, to whose office he was moved on Dec. 3. Intelligence Director John Negroponte outlined DeTrani’s duties as confirming intelligence reports on North Korea and filling in any gaps, and serving as a stand-in for...

113720618641207437

The Washington Times on ‘Seoul Train’: A new documentary on the plight of tens of thousands of North Korean defectors, perhaps several hundred thousand, who have fled the communist dictatorship into China and other countries aired recently on PBS stations. The film, “Seoul Train,” is a dramatic expose of the plight of North Koreans and the handful of activists who are trying to help them reach freedom. The documentary shows how the communist government of China is helping the North...

So What IS the Deal with Nicholas Burns?

The Washington Times reports that while Burns is not one of Secretary Rice’s inner circle from her NSC tenure, Burns is an accomplished survivor despite political changes in Washington. Mr. Burns, the department’s third-ranking official after Miss Rice and her deputy, Robert B. Zoellick, is the only career Foreign Service officer among the undersecretaries. Even though Mr. Burns, whose ability to please both Republican and Democratic administrations has taken him far and high, is considered the star of the top...

113720570831662367

“How could any good Korean dare question him?” As little as the stem cell / Dr. Hwang story interested me, the exposure and chastening of blind Korean nationalism does interest me. “Our society has been overwhelmed with the principle of focusing on outcome instead of procedure, and we forgot that ends cannot justify the means,” Chung Un Chan, president of Seoul National University, where most of Hwang’s work was conducted, said in an apology to the nation Wednesday. “Most of...

On Lee Jong-Seok, Chung Dong Young’s Replacement

The Joongang Ilbo has an excellent profile of him, including a long and detailed bio. The executive summary: he’s much smarter than Chung–which I realize isn’t saying much–and is a dyed-in-the-wool leftist academic and key theoritician behind Korea’s new neutralist policy, one that ironically depends on the presence of a large U.S. military contingent. His nomination was not well received in Washington. While I think that the significance of his lack of familiarity with the United States may be overstated,...