Deconstructing the HRC

The deconstruction of the South Korean Human Rights Commission continues in the wake of veteran Korea hand Don Kirk’s report that the HRC supports tearing down the General MacArthur statue in Incheon. I have no reason to believe that Kirk would get something this important wrong, but commenter Antti and The Marmot declare themselves incredulous, in part because the HRC didn’t publish a formal statement. [Update 8/14: Kirk and the CSM have corrected the story to reflect that the HRC...

Nukes and the U.S. Double Standard: How Dumb a Question?

The Chosun Ilbo asks why the United States is offering its limited support for nuclear programs in Iran and India, both of which are on the IAEA’s bad boy list, while refusing to allow North Korea any “peaceful” uses of nuclear energy. The headline suggests a code-yellow stupidity alert, but the article turns out to be a fair analysis, if already outdated by events. Confronting the question requires us to suspend all memory of events taking place in North Korea...

112352099255045642

Wolf Blitzer, Dumbass. One group that could stand to hire more veterans is the news business. You would think that military experience would be an important qualification for a journalist assigned to cover a war. Lacking that, how is it that CNN has the budget to hire asshats like James Carville and Robert Novak, but apparently can’t afford anyone to teach CTT to reporters who have successfully mastered the journalism programs of America’s top colleges?

The Death of an Alliance, Part 23: S. Korean Human Rights Comm’n Calls MacArthur “a war criminal who massacred numerous civilians.”

[Update: Scroll down and read the updates. Mr. Kirk and the CSM have corrected the story to reflect that the HRC did not actually take such a position. Kirk appear to have quoted the complaint, believing it was the HRC’s own position. Thanks to readers Antti and Aaron for asking the specific questions that caused me to contact Don Kirk and ask him for verification. ] When my wife first showed me the the comments of Prof. Kang Jeong-Ju, South...

Signs of the Times: So This Is Why I Spent Four Years in Korea

Above: 1950. A Marine plays taps over the graves of just a few of the 33,629 Americans killed in action in Korea. Below: August 2005. South Korean demonstrators show their appreciation for their prosperity and freedom of speech by standing at the entrance to a soccer match holding signs that say, “American soldiers not admitted.” The U.S. team was not playing. Isolated incident? No. Barring American soldiers from Korean businesses is quite common, as I can attest from personal experience,...

Over, at Last

The BBC reported the inevitable conclusion on Saturday, Washington time: Talks on North Korea’s nuclear plans are due to go into recess on Sunday for two weeks, China’s Xinhua news agency quotes a Russian official as saying. Chief negotiator Alexander Alexeyev said the talks would break up after a plenary session on Sunday morning. The North continues to deny US reports of a uranium-based capability. Three previous rounds of talks have ended in failure, but this fourth round has gone...

Justice for None

The South Koreans are asking to take jurisdiction over a soldier involved in a recent fatal traffic accident that killed a 51 year-old Korean woman pushing a yogurt cart along a street. All available evidence suggests that the death, tragic as it may have been, was accidental. The soldier was driving an Army truck, and presumably was on duty at the time. Under the U.S.-Korea Status of Forces Agreement, Article XXII, para. 3(a)(iii), the U.S. military has primary jurisdiction over...

Famine in Burma?

Whenever you read that the World Food Program is calling a situation a “food crisis” or “food shortage,” bear in mind that this is how they described the North Korean famine while millions were starving, out of a fear of offending the “host” nation. The reasons for this food shortage, incipient famine, whatever, are also analogous: Mr Morris said the government’s policy of trying to control the economy and the movement of people was to blame for the fact that...

Yet Another Talks Update

It’s bad news if you hold hope in negotiating an easy deal with North Korea, better news if you see North Korea’s self-isolation as a better outcome for the present: BEIJING, Aug. 4 – Negotiators on the North Korean nuclear program decided today to meet for at least one more day in hopes of breaking a deadlock with North Korea, even as discussions began about what might be salvaged if this round of talks ends without an agreement. The outcome...

112316720564488141

Koreans and Japanese Are Brothers! Let there be Sunshine over Tokdo! An interesting study here, although I have my doubts about who represents “Japanese,” “Chinese,” or “European” genes. Japanese from the West have a distinctly more “Korean” look than those in the Kanto Plain and further North, who tend to look more European. There are also drastic variations between the peoples of North, South, and West China. The one that would have interested me the most would have been a...